The Evolution of Success When Challenged with Hard Goals

There comes a time when being "wet and sandy" is normal.
Recent studies on U.S. Navy SEAL training - Basic Underwater Demolition/SEAL (BUD/S) reveal that psychological, mental, and identity traits often serve as better indicators of success than physical strength alone. Research shows that candidates who cultivate a new identity as a successful BUD/S student quickly, maintain their humor, and practice a "never quit" mindset are less likely to give up, even in the face of pain, cold, or exhaustion of the day-to-day grind that is SEAL training, thereby significantly increasing their chances of completing the training.
The Process of Building an Identity

Inspiration - We all get inspired to do things throughout our lives. Whether it was a person, a book, a movie, or just an idea, inspiration finds us and helps us to get started on the path.
Motivation - It is easy to be motivated to start your preparation for your future goal when you are inspired. During this period, make sure you build good habits with a clear focus on what you want to do, because one day the motivation will not be there, and you will need to rely on these habits.
Habits Become Discipline - On the day you don't feel like preparing for your goal, but you do it anyway, you have evolved from being an inspired student to a disciplined student. This is the moment identity is made, as identity is based on disciplined action, not inspired hope.
Mental and Physical Toughness - Once you start training, "even when you don't feel like it," congratulations, you are taking discipline into the realm of mental and physical toughness. You build confidence in yourself. Goals do not seem like pipe dreams anymore, and the realization of getting TO and THROUGH the goal is becoming clearer and clearer. This is the mental, physical, and character identity that needs to take place.

Then, in your first month of SEAL Training, the identity of being a BUD/S student who finishes is developed. For most, this identity does not develop largely due to a lack of preparation for the above process and for the specific events you are enduring.
Key Findings on Success in Training
Identity and Mindset: The core determinant of success is a psychological commitment to not quitting. It becomes who you are, and you do not waste time or energy thinking about not making it through training. In fact, "you will never think about quitting when you think about winning." Winning as a team, winning a race, or staying in the top 10% of any event puts you in this mindset.

Candidates who adopt a personal mantra and a mental identity as "a person who finishes what he starts" navigate the extreme stress of the first 4 weeks of the first phase of BUD/S, including Hell Week, better. Most class attrition will occur during the first four weeks of the 25-week BUD/S training. While building the identity of a successful BUD/S student must occur at BUD/S, the foundation on which that level of ability and confidence is built throughout your life. Here are some steps a student should follow during the preparation phase, long before BUD/S starts:
"Stress-is-Growth" Mindset: A study of 174 Navy SEAL candidates found that those who view stress as growth and make you tougher rather than debilitating performed better, were more persistent, and received fewer negative evaluations. Another strength is the ability to view failure or setbacks as a learning experience - not a failure. To fail once and come back stronger and smarter is what this mindset is all about.

"Not Quitting" Over Talent: People who select to join special ops programs are often high achievers. Many have never failed before in their lives. However, when failure occurs, or negative feedback from a demanding instructor staff is singularly focused on you, even the most physically fit candidates often quit if they lack the mental commitment and ability to learn from failure quickly. Whereas those who identify with never quitting will push through the "40% rule", the point where your mind tells you you're done, but your body can still go much further.
Goal Setting: Successful candidates focus on the immediate future (such as getting through the next 30 minutes) rather than the entire 6 months, breaking down the overwhelming challenge into manageable chunks. During hell week, many graduates said they broke the 120-hour event into 6-hour segments, each meal. “Make it to the next meal” was the goal of the day.
Mentorship/Role Models: Candidates who had someone in their life who allowed them to see BUD/S was not impossible were able to strongly identify with a "person who does not quit" or "warrior" mentality, often inspired by stories of past SEALs or a personal commitment to the cause, are better able to handle the immense pressure and pain. Often, “seeing is believing,” and knowing people who went before you helps students identify and say things like, “if he can make it, I can do this too.”
Key Findings on Identification and Mindset
Identity and Social Connection: A study involving 89 successful SEAL candidates found that perseverance is driven by an interaction between self-driven identity and socially-driven components. Candidates who lead themselves and identify with a resilient "will to win" are more likely to persevere through the 85% attrition rate.

Stress-is-Growth Mindset: Research following the survey found that 174 candidates who believed stress enhances their performance (rather than debilitating it) showed significantly greater persistence. This "stress-is-growth" mindset was associated with faster times on the obstacle course and fewer negative peer evaluations. This helped create a mindset in which, even when they failed, they learned from it and came back stronger on the next attempt.
Language and Commitment: Instructors have observed that words that suggest less confidence, such as "try," often signal failure. Candidates who stop using "try" in their speech completed tasks 2.6 times more frequently and reduced their quitting rate by 47%. Replace with “I will” or some other performance cue like “let’s do this,” to be more self-confident in your abilities. Positive self-talk matters significantly in your success.
Other Predictors of Success
Physical Benchmarks: Physical tests can be highly predictive, or just statistically improved odds of graduating if you can hit many of these scores in runs, swims, lifts, and calisthenics. Scores too high in any one thing usually come with a weakness in another area. For example, the best swimming student is usually one of the worst running students.

Humor: A near-universal trait among graduates is a good sense of humor, which helps manage the extreme psychological pressure of training. At the end of the day, laughing at each other’s bad day, or about an instructor who said something funny, would be just the right medicine to get you in the right mindset – that you belonged there.
The studies suggest that while physical fitness is necessary to enter training, mental fortitude and a self-identity of "not quitting" are what ensure completion.
OPTIONS: Book, eBook, Audio Book, and Video Training Course
Here is a list of what we do at StewSmithFitness.com
Core Mission
-
Tactical Fitness Training For the Candidate / Recruit: Specializing in preparing individuals for military, special ops, law enforcement, and firefighter selection programs (getting you "TO and THROUGH" training).
-
Functional Training for Both Active Duty / Recruits: Utilizing a seasonal tactical fitness periodization system that balances longer workouts of running/rucking, swimming, and calisthenics during the Spring/Summer when days are longer. Then, the focus shifts in the Fall/Winter to lifting (Cals/cardio maintenance) when the days are shorter/colder. This process has 25 years of proven success building tactical athletes who improve in all areas of fitness: strength, power, speed, agility, endurance, muscle stamina, mobility, flexibility, and grip.
Becoming an Asset for All Types: Even non-tactical athletes want to be of use in situations that require some level of fitness to get through the day. Be an asset, not a liability, in potentially dangerous situations, whether natural or man-made. Fitness can be a common denominator in successfully enduring life-or-death scenarios.
Specific Programs & Courses
-
The Ageless Athlete (Fitness Over 50): A 22-week program designed for beginners to advanced trainees looking to regain fitness, flexibility, and energy.
-
Tactical Fitness Over 40: After training people for over 25 years now, many who started with me in the early 2000s are now in their 40s and beyond. Learning how to shift training to remain an asset while also offering longevity, flexibility, and mobility is central to this 52-week program. (4-part series)
-
Tactical Fitness Course: An 80-minute course on preparing for Spec Ops selection, getting TO and THROUGH the toughest military special ops’ programs using this two-phase system.

Seasonal Tactical Fitness Periodization - A 25 Year proven system to become a tactical athlete.
-
The Never Quit Mindset Book and Course: The "Never Quit Mindset" book and course is a deep dive into building constructive habits that incrementally improve discipline, build mental toughness, and foster a Never Quit Mindset in anything you want to do.
-
Specialized Workout Plans: Specific, tailored programs for Navy SEAL (Phases 1-4), SWCC, Army (SF/Ranger/Airborne), USMC MarSOC / (RECON), Air Force (PJ/CCT), Coast Guard, Law Enforcement (FBI/DEA/FLETC), Fire Fighter, and general fitness too for beginners and advanced athletes alike.

Resources and Content
-
-
Extensive Content Library: Over 1,000 free articles, 200+ podcasts, and social media content (YouTube, TikTok, Instagram) featuring Spec Ops swim critiques and LIVE QA sessions.
- FREE Local Training for those preparing to serve! Check out HeroesofTomorrow.org for our location and schedule.

-
NEW SKOOL.com Tactical Fitness Community
-
Educational Materials: Over 40 options for eBooks, videos, printed books, podcasts (200+), and online video courses.
-
Apps: Pushup Push, Pullup Push, FBI workout, and Navy SEAL exercise apps (iPhone/Android).
-
LIVE QA Sessions Each Week: Monday and Tuesday, 9 am EST on social media platforms (YouTube, Instagram, Facebook) and Skool.com Tactical Fitness community.
-
Online Coaching: Personalized programming based on specific goals, equipment, and your time availability.
- Membership Site: Access to hundreds of weeks of training, unpublished workouts, and exclusive content, weekly newsletter sent to subscribers with the week's latest articles, videos, and workouts (beginner/intermediate, and advanced special ops prep workouts).
-
Extensive Content Library: Over 1,000 free articles, 200+ podcasts, and social media content (YouTube, TikTok, Instagram) featuring Spec Ops swim critiques and LIVE QA sessions.
Discover the Secret to Unlocking Your Best Health After 50 (latest program developed)
As you cross the wonderful milestone of 50, you might find that your body doesn’t quite bounce back the way it used to. You’re not alone in this—many men and women in your age group are searching for ways to revive their fitness levels without feeling overwhelmed. That’s where longtime coach and fitness writer Stew Smith’s newest book, "The Ageless Athlete: Fitness Over 50," comes into play. This book may just be the spark you need to ignite your fitness journey.
Truth is, there are people over 60 and 70 doing this workout. Even the advanced section. It works and will help you progress from beginner to intermediate to advanced.

Have you been thinking about getting back in shape but don’t know where to start?
Imagine waking up each day with more energy, flexibility, and the drive to embrace life head-on. Stew Smith, a seasoned fitness expert with 56 years of experience, has crafted a program specifically for guys like you—men who may feel overwhelmed by fitness options or unsure what’s suitable for their age. With his 22-week plan tailored to beginners, intermediates, and advanced practitioners, you will find exactly what you need to suit your current fitness level.
Training is What We Do:
Need Programming for Fitness Tests and Beyond? We are all about getting you TO and THROUGH your future training program. See how that works.
New Tactical Fitness Training Course!
Getting TO the training does not guarantee you get THROUGH the training. Learn about the two phases of tactical fitness you need to develop thoroughly before getting to BUDS. Check out the Online Course - Getting TO and THROUGH Special Ops Selection.
Who is Stew Smith? Coach, Trainer, Author, Podcaster
I'm the former Navy SEAL that special ops candidates go to for books, ebooks and online coaching to prepare themselves to get to and through intense tactical assessment and selection programs and qualify for service in their chosen tactical profession. See More at StewSmithFitness.com
Where to Find More Information About Optimal Performance Training Programs
When you start training again, consider the seasonal tactical fitness model. I call it A WAY to train, and obviously not the only way to train. But it offers the opportunity to never neglect your weaknesses, helps with flexibility and mobility, but will also put you at a level of physical abilities where you are happy with your overall ability to just about anything. We have a system where the seasons dictate our training. When it is nicer outside, we tend to run and do more calisthenics. When it is colder and not so nice, we lift more, run, less, and still maintain our outdoor activities with shorter runs and rucks. Check it out: Seasonal Tactical Fitness Periodization System.
Online Coaching Options
Online PT CLUB - Weekly Workouts created personally for you.
New Member's Only Content / Services Program!
If you want access to years' worth of workouts, many of the top eBOOKs, favorite workouts of the week, a free fitness APP, a closed Facebook Group, a video/picture library of exercises, and more access to LIVE Q/A sessions, check out the Stew Smith Fitness Members Section.
The dashboard below has the links to all the information, archives, videos, and links to workouts, podcasts, live Q and A lessons.
Consider this! - A Membership Program and Gain Access to Exclusive Content
(click for Fitness Club Dashboard - members only)
