Selection Prep: Understanding Why the Best Athletes Often Quit

It Comes Down to Stress, Fatigue, and Workload Management

People ask me why top-tier athletes often fail Special Ops selections. It often surprises any observer that someone will quit when they have never failed anything before and were above average in all the typical pre-selection assessments. See Spec Ops Assessment Tool for more information.

Getting accepted into a high-attrition tactical training pipeline, whether it is a police academy, fire academy, or a grueling special operations selection program like Navy SEAL training, is only the first step. All it requires is passing a basic fitness test. Too many candidates focus entirely on passing their initial fitness tests, failing to realize that the true test of selection is not a single maximum effort, but the ability to endure, recover, and perform day after day. That is the Test!

To successfully graduate, candidates must shift their mindset from simple fitness tracking to comprehensive workload management. Here is what it takes to build the physical and mental capacity required for the tactical professions.

The Hidden Variables of Training Stress

When most people think of a workout, they think only of the specific activity: running, swimming, or lifting. However, training stress comes from much more than the activity itself. For instance, doing most of your training outside builds resilience and prepares your body for hot, cold, humid, or arid conditions, which is one way to add stress.  

The physical demand/stress of a session is constantly affected by variables, including:

  • Volume, intensity, duration, and frequency
  • Training recovery intervals
  • External load, terrain, and equipment (hills, stairs, soft sand, open water)
  • Environmental conditions (heat, cold, humidity)
  • Discomfort: dirty, sweaty, sandy, and wet.

All of these offer an opportunity to add a stressor to training. Sleep, hydration, nutrition, daily work demands, and personal stress all heavily influence how your body responds to and recovers from these physical stressors.

Fatigue: Understanding The Grind

Fatigue is a guaranteed, expected outcome of challenging training, especially when preparing for consecutive days. The individual events are not the most challenging. The grind of multiple events that fit into early mornings, long days, and working into the night, day after day, can get to even the best-trained student. A history of long days and hard nights of work, school, sports, and workouts is often what people need to see to succeed. However, candidates must understand the difference between the two primary types of fatigue:

  1. Event Fatigue: This develops during or shortly after a recent bout of work. It is the immediate burning in your muscles or shortness of breath. A log PT session on Monday morning will take you to a place of fatigue and muscle failure. Your ability to recover quickly during less intense time will help you get through that session and be ready for the next event of the day.

  2. Cumulative Fatigue: This is the silent killer in selection programs. Cumulative fatigue develops when repeated efforts or consecutive training days carry leftover fatigue into future work, and normal recovery cycles no longer restore your usual capacity. After that, a Monday log PT session and doing a half mile of walking lunges will interfere with the four-mile timed run on Wednesday.

While you can recover quickly from a morning physical session, cumulative fatigue builds, and pace, coordination, concentration, and movement quality begin to decline. This is why repeated effort is such a critical component of tactical preparation. A candidate might perform exceptionally well during a single, fresh effort, but completely fall apart when that same activity follows earlier work, occurs later in the same day when it is 20 degrees warmer, or must be repeated across consecutive grueling days.

Weekly Event: The Four-Mile Timed Run

To understand how these variables and fatigue levels interact, consider the weekly four-mile run at BUD/S with no schedule other than low tide, so there is plenty of beach for the class to run.

On paper, the distance remains the same each week. However, the actual workload and the body's physiological response change entirely with context. That four-mile run could be:

  • An easy, conversational aerobic session after adequate recovery if the test is on Monday after a weekend of rest and recovery.
  • A highly demanding effort immediately following high-repetition calisthenics.
  • A grueling, muscle/joint-taxing challenge performed the day after a butt-kicking land portage session of running boats on soft sand.

Understanding these differences is what helps guide smart training decisions, ultimately preparing candidates to build the durable capacity needed for repeated work. While a 4-mile timed run may be easy for you now, 1-2 months into selection may offer a different reality. 

Building a Resilient, Comprehensive Plan

Your training history and your current physical capacity dictate exactly where your preparation should begin. At StewSmithFitness.com, we have specific programming to help you prepare for the fitness test, as well as everything else. Choose the specific selection prep programs or the Tactical Fitness Periodization programs that help you address athletic weaknesses while maintaining your current strengths.

Finally, do not underestimate the power of recovery. Integrating easier training periods deliberately, often called deloads, helps manage fatigue as your preparation develops. Our Lifting Block Periodization models and Endurance Block Models include monthly deloads that let you shift focus from one element of fitness to another for a week. These periods support consistent, long-term training and give a clearer picture of whether your body has absorbed the current workload before you stack another increase on top of it. Prepare smart, manage your stress, and build the durability to thrive when the real test begins.

Questions?  Just email Stew@StewSmithFitness.com

If you want to ask questions about what program to consider or ask Stew to develop something more specific to a personal goal, let him know at Stew@stewsmithfitness.com:

But have answers to the following questions when you email Stew:

  • Are you training for a specific selection test (PST, BUD/S, SFAS)?
  • What equipment do you have available right now?
  • What is your athletic history?
  • What are your short- and long-term goals? (weight gain/loss, military/LE service?)
  • Are you looking for a written program, APP, or a more personalized approach with online coaching?

Your Mission Starts Now

Let today be the day you refuse to quit. Let today be the day you adopt a mindset that transforms setbacks into comebacks. Join the Never Quit Mindset revolution and discover your limitless potential.

Act now—seize your $100 savings and begin the transformation that will last a lifetime.


Buy Now!
Never Quit Mindset Book, eBook, Audio Book, and 
Online Video / Audio Course


Transform Your Goals, Overcome Challenges, and 
Build Unbreakable Resilience

Discover The Never Quit Mindset by Stew Smith—a transformative personal development resource designed for motivated individuals seeking to break through barriers and achieve lasting success. Whether you're striving for excellence in your career, health, or personal life, this guide provides the tools to develop the discipline needed to conquer obstacles and fulfill your potential.

There is More To StewSmithFitness.com than You May Know

Dive deeper into the world of Tactical Athlete training and mental toughness by exploring Stew Smith Fitness Programming for the Tactical Athlete online store. Uncover the strategies and techniques used by elite forces to push past physical and mental barriers. Visit StewSmithFitness.com now and equip yourself with the tools for success in many special ops-level selection programs in the military and police world. 

Here is a list of what we do at StewSmithFitness.com

Who is Stew Smith? Coach, Trainer, Author, Podcaster 

I'm the former Navy SEAL that special ops candidates go to for books, ebooks and online coaching to prepare themselves to get to and through intense tactical assessment and selection programs and qualify for service in their chosen tactical profession.  See More at StewSmithFitness.com

Core Mission

Specific Programs & Courses

Resources and Content

Discover the Secret to Unlocking Your Best Health After 50 (latest program developed)

As you cross the wonderful milestone of 50, you might find that your body doesn’t quite bounce back the way it used to. You’re not alone in this—many men and women in your age group are searching for ways to revive their fitness levels without feeling overwhelmed. That’s where longtime coach and fitness writer Stew Smith’s newest book, "The Ageless Athlete: Fitness Over 50," comes into play. This book may just be the spark you need to ignite your fitness journey.

Truth is, there are people over 60 and 70 doing this workout. Even the advanced section. It works and will help you progress from beginner to intermediate to advanced. 


Remember, as you age, your training needs to adapt.


Have you been thinking about getting back in shape but don’t know where to start?

Imagine waking up each day with more energy, flexibility, and the drive to embrace life head-on. Stew Smith, a seasoned fitness expert with 56 years of experience, has crafted a program specifically for guys like you—men who may feel overwhelmed by fitness options or unsure what’s suitable for their age. With his 22-week plan tailored to beginners, intermediates, and advanced practitioners, you will find exactly what you need to suit your current fitness level.

Training is What We Do: 

Need Programming for Fitness Tests and Beyond?  We are all about getting you TO and THROUGH your future training program.  See how that works.  

New Tactical Fitness Training Course!

Getting TO the training does not guarantee you get THROUGH the training. Learn about the two phases of tactical fitness you need to develop thoroughly before getting to BUDS. Check out the Online Course - Getting TO and THROUGH Special Ops Selection.

Where to Find More Information About Optimal Performance Training Programs

When you start training again, consider the seasonal tactical fitness model.  I call it A WAY to train and obviously not the only way to train. But it offers the opportunity to never neglect your weaknesses, improves flexibility and mobility, and puts you at a level of physical ability where you are happy with your overall ability to do just about anything. We have a system where the seasons dictate our training. When it is nicer outside, we tend to run and do more calisthenics.  When it is colder and not so nice, we lift more, run less, and still maintain our outdoor activities with shorter runs and rucks. Check it out: Seasonal Tactical Fitness Periodization System.  

Online Coaching Options

Online Coaching is Available with Stew Smith Fitness - Weekly Workouts created personally for you.


New Members' Only Content / Services Program!

If you want access to years' worth of workouts, many of the top eBOOKs, favorite workouts of the week, a free fitness APP, a closed Facebook Group, a video/picture library of exercises, and more access to LIVE Q/A sessions, check out the Stew Smith Fitness Members Section. 

The dashboard below has the links to all the information, archives, videos, and links to workouts, podcasts, live Q and A lessons. 

Consider this! - A Membership Program and Gain Access to Exclusive Content
(click for Fitness Club Dashboard - members only)

Best of all, if you have questions, email Stew Smith himself (Stew@stewsmithfitness.com).  Join the tactical fitness group discussions, latest articles, LIVE QA videos, swim critiques, podcasts, and much more at the Stew Smith Tactical Fitness Training Closed Group on Skool.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.