From Hard Gainer to Hard Loser (Weight Gain and Weight Loss Through the Decades)

When Losing Weight Is a Little Harder to Do Than It Used to Be

Oh, to be 18 years old again - All that energy!

It can feel unfair. You go from being able to eat an entire pizza in your twenties without gaining an ounce to feeling like you gain weight just by looking at a pizza in your forties. Here is the question I have been trying to figure out for the last 20+ years: What gives and how do we help make this inevitable process more of a gentle slope through middle age and beyond?

As a hard-gaining teen, if you were into working hard to gain weight, you piled on extra calories, lifted weights, and focused on good sleep to ensure growth was in an optimal state. The old saying I used to live by: “If you want to be big, you need to eat big and lift big.” It worked, but it was tough and likely led to habits of overeating that have made eating less to lose weight more challenging. But that was not a big deal in my teens and twenties, and even in my early 30s, as I could usually outwork my eating. Then something changed.

18 Yr Old Me After 6 Years of Lifting and Eating, It Started to Work

While it feels like a sudden betrayal by your own body, what’s happening is a slow, interconnected shift in your eating habits, activity levels, hormonal changes, stress from more responsibilities in life, and body composition compared to when you were younger. Here is a breakdown of exactly what changes inside the human body to turn a "hard gainer" into someone who struggles to lose weight (aka hard loser).

1. The Loss of Muscle Mass (Sarcopenia)

This is the biggest culprit. Starting around age 30, the human body naturally begins to lose muscle mass, a process called sarcopenia. If you aren't actively strength training, you can lose anywhere from 3% to 8% of your muscle mass per decade.

• Why it matters: Muscle is an incredibly metabolically active tissue; it burns calories even when you are just sitting on the couch. 
  
  
• The shift: As your muscle mass drops, your Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) - the number of calories your body needs just to live your life - drops with it. You simply burn fewer calories by existing than you did when you were 20. More protein, strength, and power training matter – see study. 

2. Hormonal Shifts

Hormones control where your body stores fat and how it burns energy. As we age, the following start to occur:

• In men, testosterone levels gradually decline. Testosterone is crucial for maintaining muscle mass and keeping deep abdominal fat at bay.
  
  
• In women, leading up to and during menopause, estrogen levels drop significantly. This shift signals the body to stop storing fat in the hips and thighs and start storing it in the abdomen (visceral fat), which is much more stubborn to lose.
  
  
• Growth Hormone: Growth hormone (which helps repair tissue and regulate metabolism) peaks in youth and plummets as we age.
  
  We can help create more HGH by doing higher intensity training like sprints. Study on HGH/sprinting

Decline in Cellular Energy (Mitochondrial Function)

Inside your cells, tiny power plants called mitochondria turn food into energy. When you are a teenager or young adult, your mitochondria are highly efficient.

As you age, mitochondrial function naturally declines. Your cells become less efficient at turning nutrients into usable energy, making it easier for the body to store those unburned nutrients as fat instead.

To improve this process and make the decline less steep, focus on higher intensity training, aerobic exercise, and lifting/calisthenics. Physical exercise is a requirement. Secondly, eat highly nutrient-dense foods that contain antioxidants, such as polyphenols found in fruits and vegetables. Also, omega-3 fats found in fish, avocados, and olive oil are needed. Supplement these if needed: CoQ10, B vitamins, magnesium, ALA (alpha-lipoic acid) and sleep well consistently.

Insulin Sensitivity Drops

As we get older, our cells often become a bit more resistant to insulin, the hormone responsible for clearing sugar out of our bloodstream. When your body becomes less sensitive to insulin, it has to pump out more of it to get the job done. High levels of insulin in the blood signal the body to store fat rather than burn it.

The above nutrition, exercise, and sleep process helps with this, but avoiding simple sugars, adding more fiber, and learning stress-mitigation skills can also help you naturally with this part of the process.

NEAT Decreases (The "Fidget" Factor)

When you were younger, you likely had higher levels of NEAT (Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis). This includes all the energy expended for everything we do that is not sleeping, eating, or sports-like exercise, such as walking to class, fidgeting, pacing, and moving around.

As we age, we naturally tend to become more sedentary, sit for longer periods at work, and move less throughout the day, significantly reducing our daily calorie burn without us even realizing it. This is a big part of the process, and you need to find ways to take short exercise breaks throughout the day. A 10-minute walk after lunch, parking farther from the store, and taking the stairs instead of the elevator are easy ways to add more movement to a sedentary day.

The Bottom Line: When you were a "hard gainer," your body had peak hormone levels, higher muscle mass, greater activity levels, and hyper-efficient cells demanding constant fuel. As you age, your internal engine downsizes. You aren't necessarily doing anything wrong; your body has just changed the rules of the game.

To counteract this shift, the focus usually must move away from just "eating less" and toward resistance training (to protect and build that muscle engine) and toward protein and nutrient density to match your body's evolving metabolic pace. For me, as a hard loser for 20 years now, I have found the continued strength training with weights and calisthenics, a wide range of cardio (swim, bike, jog, ruck, walk), and eating nutritiously (and less than previous decades), and a good night’s sleep are all necessary for weight loss. I cannot just work out harder anymore – my life just does not allow for it at 57.

There is More To StewSmithFitness.com than You May Know

Dive deeper into the world of Tactical Athlete training and mental toughness by exploring Stew Smith Fitness Programming for the Tactical Athlete online store. Uncover the strategies and techniques used by elite forces to push past physical and mental barriers. Visit StewSmithFitness.com now and equip yourself with the tools for success in many special ops-level selection programs in the military and police world.